US
US top court rejects appeal against graphic anti-smoking images
字号+ Author:Smart News Source:Sports 2025-01-14 18:27:46 I want to comment(0)
The US Supreme Court declined on Monday to decide whether federally mandated warnings on cigarette packs that graphically illustrate the health risks of smoking violate the free speech rights of tobacco companies opposed to the labels. The justices turned away an appeal by RJ Reynolds and other tobacco companies of a lower court's ruling that found that a set of health warnings required by the US Food and Drug Administration did not violate the rights of the companies under the US Constitution's First Amendment. The action by the justices means the lower court's ruling stands. The rule was adopted by the agency in 2020 during Donald Trump's first presidential administration. The FDA required that warnings about the risks of smoking occupy the top 50% of cigarette packs and top 20% of advertisements. The regulation is technically in effect, but the FDA has generally withheld enforcing it amid legal challenges. The set of 11 warnings include depictions of feet with amputated toes, a baby whose fetal growth had been stunted, and a woman with a large protrusion in her neck caused by cancer, along with written descriptions of various health risks. RJ Reynolds, which is part of British American Tobacco, ITG Brands, which is part of Imperial Brands IMB.L, Liggett, which is part of Vector Group, and other tobacco companies sued in 2020 to challenge the warning labels. The companies claimed, among other things, that the health warnings violated their free speech rights by compelling the companies to endorse the US government's anti-smoking message through images they said misrepresented or exaggerated health consequences of smoking. US smoking rates have fallen dramatically in the past six decades, from 42.6% of American adults in 1965 to 11.6% in 2022, according to the American Lung Association. But, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, smoking still causes more than 480,000 US deaths annually. The FDA said the warnings were justified by the US government's interest in promoting greater understanding of the health risks from smoking, and reducing confusion and deception. The agency argued that the illustrated warnings were necessary because text-only warnings failed to deter teenagers from smoking. US District Judge J. Campbell Barker in Tyler, Texas, in 2022 blocked the regulation, finding that the graphic warnings violated First Amendment protections. But the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in March found that the disputed warnings were "factual and uncontroversial," thus satisfying the relevant legal standard under the First Amendment. This prompted the tobacco companies to appeal to the Supreme Court. RJ Reynolds declined on Monday to comment on the court's decision to deny its appeal. In a separate case involving the FDA, the Supreme Court on December 2 is set to hear arguments over the agency's denial of applications to sell flavored vape products.
1.This site adheres to industry standards, and any reposted articles will clearly indicate the author and source;
Related Articles
-
Kumbh Mela: India opens giant Hindu festival for 400 million pilgrims
2025-01-14 18:26
-
Azma dubs PTI protesters as ‘pseudo revolutionaries’
2025-01-14 17:45
-
Trump picks trade envoy, top economic adviser
2025-01-14 17:16
-
Judicial probe finds blatant misuse of sugar cess collection
2025-01-14 15:54
User Reviews
Recommended Reads
Hot Information
- North Gaza doctor sounds alarm over cases of malnutrition among children, adults
- Drum circle performance held at Alhamra
- Man run over by goods train
- Estimated cost of Rawalpindi Ring Road project goes up to Rs39 billion
- IMF okays review of Sri Lanka’s $2.9bn bailout
- SBP profit, PDL help govt retire Rs1.9tr debt
- Section 144 imposed in Swat over environment, public safety concerns
- Ukraine says war has damaged most of its civilian airports
- PSX appoints Farrukh as CEO
Abont US
Follow our WhatasApp account to stay updated with the latest exciting content